Maximum penalties are not a tariff
For the most serious UK GDPR infringements, the higher ceiling is £17.5 million or 4% of total worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher. Other infringements have a lower ceiling. Which limit applies depends on the legal provision involved; there is no standard price for a missing sentence in a notice.
The ICO's fining guidance assesses seriousness and the circumstances rather than applying a simple menu of offences. A sensible risk report should therefore name the suspected failing, explain the evidence and identify the relevant obligation. It should not claim that a business will receive a particular fine merely because an automated website scanner found something.
PECR exposure has changed
The enhanced PECR penalty powers commenced on 5 February 2026. The ICO can now impose penalties up to £17.5 million or 4% of global turnover under that regime. Material still describing £500,000 as the universal current PECR maximum is out of date; the timing of the conduct and transitional provisions can matter.
That change makes it especially important to distinguish electronic marketing and device-access rules from general data protection duties. It does not mean that every cookie or marketing error attracts the ceiling. Businesses should focus on whether their actual messaging and tracking practices satisfy the applicable conditions, not simply replace one frightening number with another.
Regulatory action is wider than fines
The ICO explains that helping organisations improve is an important part of its work. Depending on the circumstances, engagement, advice and corrective action may matter more than a monetary penalty. Serious or persistent failures can attract stronger intervention, and organisations should not assume that small size removes the risk.
From a management perspective, the immediate issue may be a requirement to change a process, stop an activity or produce evidence. A business relying heavily on a marketing database should consider the operational effect of discovering that it cannot justify its use. That exposure exists even where no one can responsibly forecast a fine.
Separate compensation from regulatory penalties
A regulatory fine is not the same thing as compensation to an individual. Claims for damage or distress involve separate legal questions, and the ICO does not award compensation. It is inaccurate to multiply website visitors by an assumed payout and present the result as the company's inevitable liability.
Our recommendation is to record potential consequences in separate columns: regulatory response, individual claims, investigation costs, remedial work and trading disruption. Seek appropriate legal advice on an actual claim. Do not let a consultant's sales calculation stand in for an assessment of the facts, causation and applicable law.
The costs that are easiest to overlook
Management time, forensic support, customer communications and rebuilding systems can all consume resources during a serious incident. A business may also have to answer supplier or customer questions before it can resume normal work. These are practical planning considerations, not fixed statutory charges.
A useful tabletop exercise asks who could authorise urgent technical work, who knows what information is held and who would handle incoming concerns. If those answers depend on one person being available, resilience deserves attention. Improving the response often has value beyond privacy because the same records help with continuity and supplier management.
Prioritise evidence and harm reduction
Start with processing that could cause significant harm or affects many people. Check access controls, marketing permissions, sensitive records and the ability to honour people’s choices. Fix known defects, record the decision and verify the correction. A revised document is not enough where the underlying system still behaves differently.
Keep reporting balanced. Distinguish an observed issue from a possible issue requiring investigation, and label recommendations separately from legal requirements. That gives directors something they can use: a proportionate sequence of actions, supported by evidence, rather than a generic warning that everything is high risk. Good privacy work should reduce uncertainty, not use it as a sales technique.
Sources and further reading
Primary guidance behind this briefing. Requirements depend on the facts; check the current guidance before making a decision.
This is general guidance, not a legal opinion on your circumstances or a guarantee of compliance. An individual assessment may be needed, particularly where sensitive information, disputed rights or regulatory action is involved.