First decide whether this is marketing
A message can be personal and still promote a service. Calling it a catch-up, update or invitation does not determine the rules. Equally, an ordinary operational message about an existing service is not automatically marketing. Assess the content and purpose rather than the subject line.
Our recommended review is to read the proposed email without the greeting. What is the recipient being encouraged to do? If the answer is buy, subscribe or explore a promotional offer, treat the marketing question seriously. Avoid mixing unnecessary promotion into essential service messages, because that makes both the legal assessment and the recipient’s expectations less clear.
The products-and-services soft opt-in has several conditions
For unsolicited electronic marketing to individual subscribers, consent is generally required unless a relevant soft opt-in applies. Under the products-and-services route, you must have obtained the details directly during a sale or negotiations for one, market your own similar products or services, and have offered an opt-out both at collection and in each subsequent message.
All those elements matter. A purchased list does not become your soft-opt-in list. Nor does a prior transaction repair the absence of an opt-out when the address was collected. A general promise that an address is GDPR compliant does not explain which permission applies to the proposed campaign.
Reconstruct the collection evidence
Before importing an old spreadsheet into an email platform, find the original forms, booking journey or recorded process. What did the person see? Was there an appropriate opportunity to refuse marketing? Can you connect that process to the records you intend to use?
As an operational recommendation, classify records into evidenced permission, uncertain and excluded. Keep the uncertain group out of the campaign while it is assessed. Do not silently fill gaps with the assumption that the customer must have agreed. Record the reason for each inclusion so a later colleague does not have to repeat the investigation.
Similar services require a real assessment
The issue is what the person would reasonably expect in the context of the earlier interaction. A familiar brand or common owner does not make every new venture similar. A new category of service, another company’s offering or a markedly different purpose can change the position.
Write down the connection between the old purchase and the new campaign. If the explanation relies mostly on the business wanting to expand, rather than the customer’s likely expectation, that is a reason to pause. Separate clearly relevant campaigns from speculative cross-selling instead of treating the entire customer base as one audience.
UK GDPR still applies to personal information
Meeting the PECR route does not remove the need for a lawful basis under UK GDPR. Legitimate interests may be relevant when using a soft opt-in, but the purpose, necessity and balance against the individual’s interests still need consideration. People have an absolute right to object to use of their personal data for direct marketing.
Keep a suppression record so an objection is not undone by the next list import. In practice, this means reconciling the newsletter platform, CRM and any manual mailing process. Deleting a contact from one tool without preserving the objection elsewhere can make accidental re-contact more likely.
Make stopping messages straightforward
An opt-out should be easy to understand and use. Test the route before sending a campaign, including on a phone. Do not ask people to create an account simply to stop receiving marketing. If replies are offered as an opt-out, make sure somebody monitors them and updates the relevant records.
Consider frequency and usefulness as well as technical permission. An old relationship does not guarantee that repeated messages will be welcome. Review complaints, bounces and objections, but do not mistake a lack of replies for evidence of consent. The strongest campaign is one where relevance, evidence and respectful handling all point in the same direction.
Check recipient type rather than guessing
Different PECR rules apply to corporate subscribers. Sole traders and some partnerships are not treated like limited companies simply because the email concerns business. If your historic list mixes them, segment it before deciding the route. This guide concerns commercial marketing; charities have a separate charitable-purpose soft opt-in with its own conditions.
Sources and further reading
Primary guidance behind this briefing. Requirements depend on the facts; check the current guidance before making a decision.
This is general guidance, not a legal opinion on your circumstances or a guarantee of compliance. An individual assessment may be needed, particularly where sensitive information, disputed rights or regulatory action is involved.